> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.mantelen.no/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# “That's not a thing I can say”
- URL: https://www.mantelen.no/mainwaring/
- Published: 2026-11-02T06:45:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-03T09:54:51.000Z
- Description: She has been ordained for 26 years and has been Bishop of Hertford in the Church of England since 2023. Three of the more than 200 churches in her care do not recognise her as their bishop.
- Author: Maria Solbak Årnes
- Tags: Teologi, Veirydderen, Kvinnelige prester, Kvinnelige prester. Dialogen, #mantelen, #veirydder-kvinne, #kun-veirydderen, #veirydder-side-right

Kvinnelige prester. Dialogen · Del 67

**She has been ordained for 26 years and has been Bishop of Hertford in the Church of England since 2023\. Three of the more than 200 churches in her care do not recognise her as their bishop.**

Av Maria Solbak Årnes · Video conversation with Jane Mainwaring, Bishop of Hertford, Church of England · 14 October 2026 · 2 November 2026

## A busy church life

For the last four days, I've been on a pilgrimage with some young adults from our diocese. I didn't wear my clerical wear on those occasions because we were journeying together. They knew who I was, but a lot of my role is going into spaces where I don't know people, they don't know me. And so it's helpful when I turn up at a church, for instance, they can spot who I am.

MARIA Would you mind starting by telling me something about where you are in life right now and where you are working?

Yeah, so I've been ordained for 26 years, but alongside working in the church, I'm also married and I have two adult children. So I have sort of a busy church life as well as a busy family life.

And I currently work in Hertfordshire, which is part of the diocese of St Albans, and that covers both the county of Hertfordshire and the county of Bedfordshire. But I focus most of my time in Hertfordshire, and that's why I'm known as Bishop of Hertford. That's my role.

MARIA Do you have any special areas of interest that are sort of your own project?

The nature of what I do means that there's not much time to do individual projects, because my role is very much one of supporting other people doing the ministry.

But I have particular passions and interests, and working with young people and young adults is one of the things I try and give time to in a busy diary. And I also do quite a lot of work nationally around people who are discerning what God might be calling them to, particularly into ordained ministry. It wouldn't be a project, but it's a piece of work in an area of church life that I have a particular responsibility for.

Fakta

**Jane Mainwaring** was ordained deacon in 2000 and priest in 2001, after training on the East Anglian Ministerial Training Course. She served her title at St Gregory's, Sudbury, in the diocese of St Edmundsbury and Ipswich, and was then team vicar in Hitchin for 17 years and rural dean of Hitchin. She became Archdeacon of St Albans in 2020 and was consecrated Bishop of Hertford in Canterbury Cathedral on 2 February 2023\. Before ordination she completed a PhD at Trinity College, Carmarthen, on Church of England and Church in Wales primary schools. Sources: [Church Times, 25 November 2022](https://churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2022/25-november/news/uk/archdeacon-mainwaring-to-be-next-bishop-of-hertford?ref=mantelen.no), [Wikipedia: Jane Mainwaring](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jane%5FMainwaring?ref=mantelen.no).

## Possibly, but not yet

MARIA When did the journey start? When did you decide, okay, I'm going to be ordained?

Yeah, so I was in my early 20s when people increasingly asked me whether I had ever thought about being ordained. And for a number of years, my response was, possibly, but not yet.

And then I began working with a chaplain at a college, and we had the same conversation, whether I'd ever thought about it, and I said yes, but not yet. And she basically told me to get on with it and nagged me through the lengthy discernment process that takes place. So I always think if it wasn't for her, I probably wouldn't be doing this now. I needed someone to sort of push me to take that next step.

So I always think if it wasn't for her, I probably wouldn't be doing this now.

MARIA So can you say that you were called?

Yes, yes. So I would talk about calling in three different ways. Sometimes we have an inner sense of what we are being called to, and God calls, obviously, but the church also calls. And in that sense, I mean, other people saying, I think you should think about this, or the church saying, actually, we want you to think about this role.

And my experience has been, you need all three. You need to believe that God is calling you, you need to have that inner sense of, in my gut, in my soul, I think this is what I am called to do. But you also need people outside to be saying, actually, we think this is what you're called to do as well.

And I am much better at hearing when the church calls than when, I think, inside, that might be my own thoughts. Because that's confirmation then, rather than me thinking, that can't possibly be right, I can't possibly do that. Whereas when the church says, actually, you can, we want you to think about it, that carries quite a lot of weight.

## Mutual flourishing

MARIA And the church also has different views on women having the role of priests or ministers.

So the Church of England decided in 1992 that women could be ordained as priests. And for various reasons, because we are an established church, so it had to go through Parliament, that sort of thing, the first women were ordained as priests in 1994\. And women weren't able to be bishops until 2014.

So the Church of England has been on a journey with this ministry. And we are still in a position where there will be some in the Church of England, the minority, but there are some churches and some people who won't receive my ministry. So they would not recognize me as their bishop, because I'm a woman.

So they would not recognize me as their bishop, because I'm a woman.

MARIA But isn't that hard to grasp? One church will say, yes, you should become a minister, and another church will say, no, you shouldn't. Then how do you know who to listen to?

I think the Church of England as a whole has decided that women can be priests and they can be bishops. It's the local churches, so individual local churches or individual people, who feel that they can't accept the ministry of women. So it's not the church nationally. The church nationally has decided.

But in that decision making process, there was room and space allowed for those who feel this has not been the right decision. So when the Church of England decided to ordain women as priests and women as bishops, it wasn't a matter of everybody has to agree or leave. In a desire to not force people to leave, we talk about the term mutual flourishing. That is where we are seeking to enable everyone to flourish well in the church, respecting that there are differences on this.

MARIA How's that working?

Yeah, it's not always easy. But the vast majority of churches have no problem with women. Out of over 200 churches that I have oversight of, there would be three that would not recognise me as their bishop.

So it's a very small group. And therefore, although it is a sadness and it can be tricky to navigate sometimes, actually the vast majority of people, it's not a problem. And therefore, it is a situation I can live with. Even if I would rather everybody recognised my ministry.

Fakta

**Women priests and bishops in the Church of England.** In 1992 the General Synod approved the ordination of women as priests with the required two-thirds majority in each of its three houses; among the laity the measure passed by two votes. On 12 March 1994, 32 women were ordained priests in Bristol Cathedral. The Act of Synod of 1993 provided bishops for parishes that could not accept women priests. In 2014 the Synod completed legislation allowing women to become bishops, and in 2015 Libby Lane became the first woman consecrated bishop. In the House of Bishops Declaration of May 2014, the fifth of five guiding principles says that provision for the minority will be made without a time limit and in a way that «contributes to mutual flourishing across the whole Church of England». Sources: [House of Bishops Declaration, GS Misc 1076](https://www.churchofengland.org/sites/default/files/2018-01/gs-misc-1076-women-in-the-episcopate-house-of-bishops-declaration%5Fjuly14.pdf?ref=mantelen.no), [Religion Media Centre, factsheet](https://religionmediacentre.org.uk/factsheets/25-years-of-women-as-priests-in-the-church-of-england/?ref=mantelen.no), [Women and the Church, timeline](https://womenandthechurch.org/timeline?ref=mantelen.no).

## A person rather than an argument

MARIA Do you know what changed for the church when they went from having only men to opening up for women as well, after 2000 years? There must have been a reasoning for changing theology and view.

I think there is both a reading of scripture in a cultural setting and recognising that actually Jesus did have women as his disciples. The lack of women in leadership roles in the Bible, and some of St Paul's teaching, some would say that is an argument for why women should not be in leadership positions. Another reading of scripture says you have to take into account the culture of the time, when no women would be in leadership positions at all. And the fact that Jesus had female disciples would have been radical at that time.

So I think it's about reading of scripture, going alongside the cultural changes. I look at English society, and 100 years ago it would have been very rare to have women at the top of businesses and companies and that sort of thing. And now we talk in terms of the glass ceiling in a lot of places having been broken. We've had female prime ministers. So as our culture has changed, the danger is we seem to be out of step.

And there are some things, as culture changes, that you think, actually, I want to be out of step with culture, because actually it goes against what's taught by Jesus. But I think the decision was made, a decision I support, that actually women should be free to explore where God is calling them to.

And I think over the last 30, what are we now, 32 years, 33 years of women being allowed to be priests and therefore allowed to run churches, we have seen the evidence of God working through those women. And I think that has enabled more and more people to come to a settled position.

So when I was first ordained, my first church, when I arrived, there were six individuals or couples that said they would never come to the church again because I was a woman. And by the end of my time there, they had all returned to church.

And by the end of my time there, they had all returned to church.

And so sometimes I think people are afraid of change. And it takes time for people to get used to change. But then they see the outworking of it, and see a person rather than an argument in front of them. Because you can move from a theoretical argument to, actually, you've now got somebody in front of you who is living out that role. And it changes a lot. And you put the personal in.

## Not pretending to be a man

MARIA But how about your view? Has that changed over the years? When you were getting your education, I suppose the issue of women as priests was discussed in some sense?

A little bit. I think I was never not in favor of women being ordained. But the bit that I had to work through was how a woman could run a church, because I've grown up with men running churches. And so the question for me was, how does a woman run a church and do it in a way that she's not pretending to be a man? If that makes sense.

And actually the chaplain who I worked with and who nagged me through the selection process was the first female priest I had worked with. And watching her ministry made a huge difference to my own sense of accepting that it is possible to do this role.

And it looks different, because it's a woman occupying the role rather than the man. She didn't ever feel she had to change who she was or how she was to fill the role. Which meant that it was done differently, but done equally effectively. And I think having that sort of role model was really important for me. And it enabled me to sort of go, okay, I can see me now doing the role.

She didn't ever feel she had to change who she was or how she was to fill the role.

## Male and female

MARIA If we agree that men and women are different, then I guess the conversation will go smoother. I don't know how the status is in England when it comes to gender or sex and the difference.

So we've had some difficult conversations over the last few years about this. There was a big debate in the last few years about whether those in same-sex relationships could have their relationship blessed in a church. So at the moment, we can't marry people of the same sex in the Church of England. But whether, if they were married in a secular setting, they could come to church for a blessing. We've agreed that they can. But that has been very divisive.

And so at this point in time, we'll be going no further on that. So there'll be no further steps towards allowing same-sex couples to be married in church in the near future. And if somebody has legally changed their gender, so transitioned, they can be ordained in the church. But that is not without its controversy. But we would still talk in terms of male and female.

And for the Church of England, that is the most controversial and divisive conversation at the moment. Whereas the place of women in ministry, although there is still disagreement and it's still a slightly uncomfortable position, not having made a sort of firm, you either accept or you leave decision, it is something we have lived with for a long time now, and therefore is more settled.

MARIA And do you feel you know well the arguments and how the other side is reading the Bible?

I think they've been well rehearsed. I was very fortunate in being ordained as a priest and as a bishop after those arguments had taken place. I have not had to get involved in the politics of it or had to argue the case particularly. For which I'm actually very grateful.

## Cultural lenses

MARIA The main argument on the other side is Paul's letters. To Timothy and to the Corinthians he writes that women should be silent in church, ask their husbands at home and not teach men. He also writes that the man is the head of the woman, as Christ is the head of the man and God the head of Christ. I don't read Paul as looking down on women. But on the leader position, he grounds his answer in creation: woman was created for man, not man for woman. Do you read Paul the same way?

I would say that all of Paul's letters need to be read with the culture that he was writing into in mind. To understand best what Paul was trying to say, you need to understand the situation he was writing into. Paul was not writing letters with the mind that they would be read 2,000 years later. He was writing letters to particular early Christian communities. And within those letters there is much rich theology and some beautiful explanations of the gospel and the love of God. But you cannot get away from the fact that they were written to particular communities.

And you'll find in some of the letters that he addresses particular issues because they were issues for the church in Corinth or for the church in Ephesus. And therefore my own view would be we have to interpret what Paul writes through cultural lenses as well as through theological lenses.

And that's why, although I understand when people say, well, this is what Paul wrote, that women should be silent in churches, etc., I have long since held the view that that was driven by the cultural expectations of the day, rather than taking a letter that was written to a Christian community in a particular context a very long time ago and say, well, that has to stay true to our context.

That is where the reading of scripture comes. That's where we have to grapple with it. Because you could argue that nothing Paul writes is relevant. And I absolutely wouldn't be saying that.

But we have to understand the culture of the day, in the same way as we look at Jesus' attitude. And I'm always very wary of putting Paul above Jesus. So actually, what Paul says into one particular context, is that supported by what we know of Jesus' life and his attitudes? Because actually, Jesus is the Son of God, not Paul.

And I'm always very wary of putting Paul above Jesus.

And I think actually Jesus chose in a culture where women's voice was not heard. Where women absolutely would have been second class citizens, if not third class. And yet Jesus chose for Mary to be the first evangelist.

And so I fully appreciate other people's reading of scripture, and that really careful discernment of what do we say is culturally influenced, and what is theological truth that we have to hold on to. People will come to different places and different opinions on that. And that is what the church has grappled with throughout its history. And in that way I recognize that other people have come to a different place than I have.

Tekstene det gjelder

1 Korinter 11,3 ([MANTELEN NT](https://www.mantelen.no/bibelen/))

Men jeg vil at dere skal vite at Kristus er enhver manns hode, og mannen er kvinnens hode, og Gud er Kristi hode.

1 Korinter 11,8-9 ([MANTELEN NT](https://www.mantelen.no/bibelen/))

For mannen er ikke av kvinnen, men kvinnen av mannen. For mannen ble heller ikke skapt for kvinnens skyld, men kvinnen for mannens skyld.

1 Korinter 14,34-35 ([MANTELEN NT](https://www.mantelen.no/bibelen/))

Kvinnene deres skal tie i menighetene; for det er ikke tillatt dem å tale, men de skal underordne seg, slik også loven sier. Men hvis de ønsker å lære noe, skal de spørre sine egne menn hjemme; for det er skammelig for kvinner å tale i menigheten.

1 Timoteus 2,11-14 ([MANTELEN NT](https://www.mantelen.no/bibelen/))

En kvinne skal ta imot undervisning i stillhet, med all underordning. Men jeg tillater ikke en kvinne å undervise eller å utøve myndighet over en mann, men å være i stillhet. For Adam ble formet først, deretter Eva. Og Adam ble ikke bedratt, men kvinnen ble bedratt og er kommet i overtredelse.

Galaterne 3,28 ([MANTELEN NT](https://www.mantelen.no/bibelen/))

Her er ikke jøde eller greker, her er ikke slave eller fri, her er ikke mann og kvinne; for dere er alle én i Kristus Jesus.

## Practical advice to one church

MARIA So would it then be correct to say that you think Paul is mistaken when he is reading the creation story in this way, concluding in this way, and saying that it's from God? Is that a human error with Paul?

I wouldn't say he is mistaken. I would say the theology of Paul is one thing. His practical advice to a church in a particular context was just that. It was practical advice to a church in a particular context.

And I think that's the distinction I would make. I wouldn't say that Paul was mistaken. But I think there is an important distinction between when Paul is talking about his beliefs and when Paul is giving practical advice to a church in a particular context.

MARIA Where he tells women to be silent, he is writing to one congregation. But where he writes that the man is the head of the woman, he gives a universal reason, creation, and presents it as coming from God. If we call this cultural, it is hard not to say that Paul was wrong. Jesus promised that the Holy Spirit would guide his disciples into all the truth. Was Paul still wrong here? You are welcome to answer in writing afterwards as well.

When people ask where I think God is in a situation, I cannot help but bring the cultural lenses that I see the world through to my answer. And I would say that Paul could not help but view through his cultural lenses. And that's why I wouldn't go as far to say Paul was mistaken, because I think he saw through his cultural lenses.

He was seeking to discern, to make sense of the world in which Jesus had entered and changed our relationship with God forever. But none of us can completely take our cultural lenses off. And that's why I really would struggle to say I think Paul was mistaken. But I think he saw through his cultural lenses.

But I completely accept that there will be other readings of scripture, which say that every word is divinely inspired and therefore is true now as it was 2000 years ago. And that's where the church is with many issues. Both in the early church as well as the church that we know now.

But none of us can completely take our cultural lenses off.

Tekstene det gjelder

1 Korinter 14,37 ([MANTELEN NT](https://www.mantelen.no/bibelen/))

Hvis noen mener at han er profet eller åndelig, skal han erkjenne at de tingene jeg skriver til dere, er Herrens bud.

Johannes 16,13 ([MANTELEN NT](https://www.mantelen.no/bibelen/))

Men når han kommer, sannhetens Ånd, skal han lede dere inn i hele sannheten. For han skal ikke tale på egen hånd, men alt han hører, skal han tale, og det som skal komme, skal han kunngjøre for dere.

## The first to Mary

MARIA A very much used argument is that Jesus chose these 12 disciples that were men, and therefore the upper position should be for men. There were women that followed Jesus, and he could have chosen those, but he chose these men. And he sadly doesn't explain why he does what he does. How do you understand that, and what do you read out of it?

I think the fact that so many women are actually named in the Gospels. So we've got Mary and Martha, we've got Mary Magdalene. The fact that even Mary as a mother is given a prominent position. I think that speaks volumes. Again, sorry to keep going back to the cultural setting, but the cultural setting at the time would have been that any promotion of women doing anything would have been radical.

And actually, there are many times where Jesus holds women up as an example to the men. The washing of Jesus' feet, the anointing of Jesus' feet. This woman, who would have been absolutely the lowest of the low, she has done the better thing.

And so, again, I absolutely see and I hear the argument that says Jesus could have chosen women to be part of the 12 disciples. I think that at the time would have been culturally unacceptable. Women just didn't appear in society in that way at all. And the fact that time and time again, he did choose to. But the place of women was so valued in Jesus' ministry that it was itself deeply radical. So he was already, just by doing that, pushing against his culture of the day. The fact that I mentioned already: why did he appear first to Mary?

MARIA They didn't change her name or make her a man. It wouldn't make sense to make that up.

Because it would have been much, much easier and much more acceptable at the time for a man to have carried the message of the resurrection.

Tekstene det gjelder

Lukas 7,44 ([MANTELEN NT](https://www.mantelen.no/bibelen/))

Og han vendte seg mot kvinnen og sa til Simon: «Ser du denne kvinnen? Jeg kom inn i huset ditt; du ga meg ikke vann til føttene mine, men hun vætet føttene mine med tårene sine og tørket dem med håret på hodet sitt.

Johannes 20,17-18 ([MANTELEN NT](https://www.mantelen.no/bibelen/))

Jesus sier til henne: «Rør meg ikke, for jeg har ennå ikke steget opp til min Far. Men gå til brødrene mine og si til dem: 'Jeg stiger opp til min Far og deres Far, og min Gud og deres Gud.'» Maria Magdalena kommer og forteller disiplene at hun har sett Herren, og at han hadde sagt dette til henne.

## What we don't know

MARIA But then there's an inconsistency for me there. He used her as his first witness, but he didn't choose the women who followed him to be disciples. Maybe there are two readings of this story that you can't validate any further.

There is so much we don't know. And the Gospels as we have them, this is not Jesus writing. This is an account of his life written by others. And each Gospel is written in a particular way, because each Gospel was written for a particular audience.

And I would love to know the stuff that we don't know. The conversations, the stuff that wasn't recorded or passed down. Which would then enable us sometimes to act as a church with much more certainty. But what we have been gifted is four people's accounts of the life of Jesus, and letters from Paul and Peter, as the early church tried to work out what all this meant.

And as the early Christian communities tried to work out, what does church look like? What does being a Christian community look like? And therefore, I think there is always going to be stuff that we will have to grapple with, because we don't know the entirety. And people will come to different places in that grappling.

And we have got to discern where we feel or sense that the Holy Spirit is moving now.

## Where is God blessing

MARIA And you think it's moving in the same way that it was back then?

I think God's Holy Spirit absolutely moves in the church and in the world now. And I think sometimes, because it's not new and exciting for us, we've had Christian faith for the last 2000 years, we don't see where the Holy Spirit is moving in the same way that the first disciples did, because it was so new and radical. I think inevitably the human mind gets used to something, and therefore we stop seeing the new and looking out for the new and the radical. But I absolutely think the Holy Spirit is still moving in the church.

And I think that is another part of how we discern the church's will: we look for where the Holy Spirit is moving. And I look at some of my male and female colleagues and see God at work through their lives and their ministries. And that for me, as I mentioned earlier, seeing the female chaplain minister and seeing God work through her and seeing the fruits of that ministry, helped persuade me that, alongside my reading of Scripture, actually God was using her as a priest in the church.

And I think if you use that simple basis of, actually, where do you see God at work? What's God blessing?

MARIA What did you see that you thought of as fruit of her ministry?

So bringing people to faith in God, ministering to their needs, being a pastor, being a priest, all the things. So I saw her exercise the priestly ministry in a different way, but as an effective way as those men I've known up to that point. And I saw God work through her.

And I think if it's not of God, then God doesn't bless it. And I think for me, that's one of the biggest arguments. You can debate the theology, but God isn't constricted by the words in the Bible.

And I think if it's not of God, then God doesn't bless it.

And we have to look at where's the Holy Spirit moving now? Where do we see the fruit? And I look at the ministry of other female priests I know. And I've seen churches flourish under their leadership. I've seen people come to faith in Jesus through that leadership.

And if I were to turn around now and say, I don't believe that God is calling women to be priests in this church, then I would be saying, actually, all the fruit that I've seen over the last 30 odd years of women's priestly ministry in the Church of England, that's not of God. And that's not a thing I can say.

And that's not a thing I can say.

Tekstene det gjelder

Matteus 7,20 ([MANTELEN NT](https://www.mantelen.no/bibelen/))

Derfor skal dere kjenne dem på fruktene deres.»

## Agree or leave

MARIA Is there anything else you would like to add to the interview in relation to this theme?

I think just to say I am glad that the Church of England, when it made the decision to step forward with women's priestly and episcopal ministry, did not do a hard line and say you either have to agree or you leave. And we have to journey together and we have to hold our disagreements well, but in love and with respect for one another. And respect the fact that we have different views, arrived at after much thought and consideration and prayer.

I would rather be in a church that says we have arrived at a different place from one another, but we are still committed to journeying together, than to be in a church that says you either have to agree or you have to leave.

Not everybody in the Church of England would agree with my position, but I would much rather be in this position than to tell people they have to leave, or agree to something they don't agree to.

## Portrett

![Jane Mainwaring](https://storage.ghost.io/c/43/47/4347530e-879b-48c6-853f-9dba19c9ae72/content/images/2026/11/mainwaring-portrett-760.jpg) 

Jane Mainwaring, Bishop of Hertford. Photo: Private.

## Terskelen

Mainwaring was ordained in 2000, six years after the first women were priested in Bristol. She grew up with men running churches. A chaplain who nagged her through selection showed her a woman could do the role without pretending to be a man. She has been Bishop of Hertford since 2023\. Three of her more than 200 churches do not receive her. She can live with that.

She reads Paul through cultural as well as theological lenses. The command to silence was practical advice to one church. She will not call Paul mistaken. He saw through his lenses, she says, as all of us do. Her strongest argument is fruit. She has seen churches flourish under women. To deny that would be to call it not of God.

The editor takes one question with him. In 1 Corinthians 11:8-9 and 1 Timothy 2:13 Paul grounds his instruction in creation, and she reads his words as practical advice to one church. How does she see those reasons from creation fitting into that reading? We thank her for sharing this with us.